Florida Mediation vs Appraisal on a Water Claim Dispute

BYSteve Jafari, General ManagerMIAMI-DADE & BROWARD

Florida section 627.7015 sets up a nonbinding mediation conference for residential property claim disputes, administered by the Department of Financial Services, and the insurer must bear all of the cost of conducting it. A written settlement can be rescinded within 3 business days unless the money has been cashed or deposited, and the section 627.70131 deadlines toll while the mediation is pending. Appraisal is a contract process, so what your own policy requires is a question for your declarations page, your carrier, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney.
Call (786) 213-9489What are the two paths a Florida property claim dispute can take?
A Florida amount dispute has two named paths. Florida mediation is a state-run conference the Department of Financial Services administers under section 627.7015, and it is nonbinding. Appraisal is a contract process, so its rules sit in the policy.
Restoration Doctor is a water mitigation company, not a public adjuster and not a law firm. Nothing below is legal advice or insurance advice. Your policy and the facts of your loss set what your insurer owes. Questions about coverage belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.
| Question | State mediation under section 627.7015 | Appraisal |
|---|---|---|
| Who runs it | The department, or an administrator it designates, assigns the mediator | The policy sets the process. No statute creates it, though section 627.70152(4)(b) can require a claimant to participate in it |
| Who can ask for it | The policyholder, the insurer, or a third-party assignee whose request the insurer need not accept | The policy, plus a carrier's response to a presuit notice under section 627.70152(4)(b) |
| Who pays | The insurer must bear all of the cost of conducting the conference | Not addressed by section 627.7015, which calls appraisal potentially expensive |
| Binding | Nonbinding, with 3 business days to rescind a written settlement | Set by the policy, not by this statute |
| How soon | Within 21 calendar days of the mediator's assignment, per the department | Not set by section 627.7015 |
| Effect on the section 627.70131 clocks | Paused while it is pending | Paused while it is pending |
| A lawyer in the room | Permitted if the policyholder requests it, and not required | Set by the policy |
What is the Department of Financial Services mediation program, and who can request it?
The program is a mediated claim resolution conference run by the department, or by an administrator the department designates. Section 627.7015 describes it as a nonadversarial alternative dispute resolution procedure, and the mediator has no power to decide anything.
Who may request it and which claims are eligible is set out in section 627.7015 and on the department's mediation page. Your policy and the facts of your loss set what your insurer owes. Questions about coverage belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.

Who pays for the conference, and how fast does it happen?
Section 627.7015(3) addresses the cost of mediation conferences, and the department states the program figure on its own page. The department cites section 627.7015, Rule 69J-166.031 of the Florida Administrative Code and request form DFS-I0-2082 as its authority for the request process.
Your policy and the facts of your loss set what your insurer owes. Questions about coverage belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.
Is mediation binding, and what does requesting it do to the carrier's clock?
Section 627.7015 describes mediation as nonbinding and sets a rescission window for a written settlement. Section 627.70131(8)(a) addresses the tolling of that section's requirements while a mediation proceeding is pending. The mediator provides a written report of the results.
How these provisions apply to any particular claim is a question for an attorney or a licensed public adjuster. Your policy and the facts of your loss set what your insurer owes. Questions about coverage belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.
Which disputes are shut out of the mediation program?
Section 627.7015 defines the disputes it covers by listing the categories that fall outside the program.
- A dispute the insurer has a reasonable basis to suspect involves fraud.
- A dispute where, on agreed-upon facts as to the cause of loss, there is no coverage under the policy.
- A dispute where the insurer has a reasonable basis to believe the policyholder intentionally made a material misrepresentation of fact relevant to the claim, and the entire request for payment has been denied on that basis.
- A dispute where the amount in controversy, meaning the amount actually in dispute, is less than $500, unless the parties agree to mediate a lesser amount. The department applies that same threshold after the deductible is applied, which is the part people miss. It is the statute's figure and the department's, not ours.
- A dispute about a loss that does not comply with section 627.70132. That is a cross-reference to another statute, and whether a given loss complies with it is not a question a contractor answers.

What if a dispute falls outside those rules but both sides still want to mediate?
The department's mediation page describes the eligible subject matter, and says it requires written documentation before it will proceed on a dispute that does not meet the eligibility requirements. Whether a given dispute fits is a question for the department, or for a licensed public adjuster or an attorney.
What if the carrier never told you the program existed?
Section 627.7015(7) addresses the effect of an insurer's failure to give the notice required by subsection (2) on a contractual loss appraisal precondition to legal action. Whether a given set of facts falls inside it is a legal question for an attorney. Your policy and the facts of your loss set what your insurer owes. Questions about coverage belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.
Where does appraisal sit, and when can it become compulsory?
Appraisal is a creature of the contract. Section 627.7015 calls it a contractual loss appraisal process, and section 627.70131(8)(a) speaks of an alternative dispute resolution proceeding provided for in the insurance contract. Section 627.70152 addresses the presuit notice to the department and the insurer's permitted responses.
What appraisal requires of you turns on your policy. Your policy and the facts of your loss set what your insurer owes. Questions about coverage belong with your insurer, your agent, or a licensed public adjuster or attorney.

What can a restoration contractor do at a mediation, and what can it not do?
The department's page says the conference may also be attended by a person who can assist a party, such as contractors, adjusters, engineers and interpreters. Section 489.147(2)(d) prohibits a contractor from interpreting policy provisions, from advising an insured regarding coverages or duties under their property insurance policy, and from adjusting a property insurance claim on behalf of the insured, unless the contractor holds a public adjuster license under part VI of chapter 626.
Restoration Doctor is a water mitigation company. We invoice the property owner. You are responsible for payment under your signed agreement, whether or not your insurer pays. We give you our photos, moisture readings and invoice. They are yours to share with your insurer, or keep. We do not interpret your policy, negotiate with your insurer, or represent you in your claim. Your policy and the facts of your loss set what your insurer owes.
Where can I read the authorities for myself?
Statutes get amended and department pages get rewritten. Every source below was fetched and read on September 21, 2026. The quoted language in this post comes from those copies, so confirm the current text before relying on any of it.
Restoration Doctor is a water mitigation company. We document our mitigation work. We do not adjust claims, we do not interpret coverage, and we do not give legal advice. For anything about your own policy, speak to your insurer, your agent, a licensed public adjuster or an attorney.
| Source | Link |
|---|---|
| Florida Statutes section 627.7015, alternative procedure for resolution of disputed property insurance claims | Fla. Stat. 627.7015 |
| Florida Statutes section 627.70131, insurer's duty to acknowledge communications regarding claims, including the tolling provision at subsection (8)(a) | Fla. Stat. 627.70131 |
| Florida Statutes section 627.70152, suits arising under a property insurance policy, including the presuit notice and the insurer's permitted responses | Fla. Stat. 627.70152 |
| Florida Statutes section 489.147, prohibited property insurance practices by contractors | Fla. Stat. 489.147 |
| Florida Department of Financial Services, the residential property mediation page, with the cost, the timetable and who may attend | The department's mediation page |
| Florida Department of Financial Services, the online mediation request, alongside form DFS-I0-2082 | Request mediation online |
| Florida Department of Financial Services, Consumer Assistance Portal, for a concern about an insurer | Consumer Assistance Portal |
| Sister sites in other markets | restorationdoctors.com and restorationdoctordc.com |



