Do You Have to Use a Preferred Contractor in Florida?

BYSteve Jafari, General ManagerMIAMI-DADE & BROWARD

If it is only an optional vendor list, we found no Florida statute that requires you to use it. We read the sections that would carry a policyholder's right to pick a contractor and found none, while three preserve an insurer's own right to repair. Some policies tie payment to the insurer's program: Citizens says HO-3 and DP-3 policyholders who decline its Managed Repair Contractor Network face a $10,000 limit on non-weather water losses. The answer sits in your policy and your repair contract, so check both in writing before work starts.
Call (786) 213-9489What is an insurer's preferred contractor list?
Whether you have to use an insurer's preferred contractor in Florida is not answered by a Florida statute; it is answered by your own policy language and your own repair agreement. If it is only an optional vendor list, we found no Florida statute that requires you to use it. If your policy carries a managed repair or preferred contractor provision, declining can change or cap what the policy pays, so check for one before you hire. A preferred contractor list is a commercial arrangement between an insurance company and the companies whose names appear on it. Work is referred in one direction, under terms the two companies set between themselves.
The names vary, and the variation matters. Preferred vendor, approved vendor, program contractor and network contractor usually describe a referral. Managed repair describes something that can be written into the policy itself. Florida law uses both kinds of language in one sentence, which is the clearest available signal that they are not the same thing.
This post answers the first of the two questions hiding inside one, the kind of arrangement a list is, from public statutes you can read yourself. The second, what your own policy says, belongs to your insurance company and your agent.
Restoration Doctor is a water mitigation company, not a public adjuster, a law firm or an insurance company. Nothing here is legal advice or insurance advice, and nothing here is a reading of your policy.
Who holds the contract for the work, and who holds the policy?
An insured repair usually involves two separate contracts, and almost every misunderstanding on this subject comes from treating them as one. The insurance policy is a contract between the policyholder and the insurance company. The repair agreement is a contract between the property owner and the contractor doing the work. Different parties, different documents, different obligations.
A contractor is not a party to your insurance policy and cannot act under it. Where the homeowner signs the repair agreement, the adjuster is not a party to it. Where an insurer exercises a right to repair under its own policy, the paperwork can run differently, which is section four. Whoever signs is who the contractor answers to for scope, schedule and payment.
The first thing worth establishing is not whether a list is fair, but which document the instruction comes from. Asking the insurer to name the source in writing needs no lawyer.

Does Florida law give you a right to choose your own contractor?
We looked for one and did not find it. That is a finding about statutes, not about practice. Homeowners hire whoever they hire, and the state's own advisory list assumes it by speaking of the contractor you choose. What is missing is a section of Florida law that says so.
We read six sections in full on the Legislature's own site, because they are where such a provision would sit. Four are policy sections: the Homeowner Claims Bill of Rights, replacement cost, valued policy and repair and assignment agreements. Two are conduct sections: unfair methods of competition and prohibited property insurance practices by contractors. None grants a policyholder a right to select the contractor who performs insured repairs.
The Homeowner Claims Bill of Rights is the most telling of the six: it is the state's own plain-language summary of existing Florida law for claimants. Its enumerated rights run from claim acknowledgment and a coverage confirmation on written request to free state mediation and a state helpline. Contractor choice is not among them.
Florida's unfair methods of competition section is equally clear by absence. On November 21, 2026 we searched the full current text of the section, through its history note, on the Legislature's own site: the words repair, contractor, shop and steer do not appear in it. Its unfair claim settlement practices list reaches conduct such as misrepresenting policy provisions and denying claims without reasonable investigation, where it is performed with such frequency as to indicate a general business practice. It is not about who does the work.
One contrast is worth naming, because it shows the Legislature knows how to write this kind of rule. Florida does address an insurer that directs a repair, but only for vehicles. Fla. Stat. 626.9743 says an insurer that elects to repair a motor vehicle and specifically requires a particular repair shop must restore it to its pre-loss condition at no added cost to the insured beyond the policy terms. That provision lets the insurer require a shop, then attaches a condition to it. No parallel provision was located for residential property repair.
Two honest limits on that finding. The Legislature's full-text statute search would not run for us over a plain page request today, so this is a careful reading of the sections that would carry such a provision, not a survey of every line of Florida law. And a question about one specific policy is a question for a licensed Florida attorney or a licensed public adjuster, neither of which we are.
What does Florida law say about an insurer's own right to repair?
Here the statutes are not silent, and they do not run the homeowner's way. Three sections preserve an insurance company's ability to repair rather than pay, where its policy provides for it. The replacement cost section ends with a list of things it does not do, and one of them is this: it does not prohibit an insurer from exercising its right to repair in compliance with its policy and section 627.702(7).
Section 627.702(7) says: "Nothing herein shall be construed as prohibiting an insurer from repairing or replacing damaged property at its own expense and without contribution on the part of the insured". Where a policy gives the insurer that option, the statutes leave it in place.
The Homeowner Claims Bill of Rights carries the same limit on its own face. It says the document does not enlarge, modify or contravene statutory requirements, does not prohibit an insurer from exercising its right to repair in compliance with an applicable policy or the two sections above, and creates no civil cause of action for a policyholder.
Florida's assignment of benefits reform did not disturb any of this. The assignment section states that an assignment agreement and that section do not modify or eliminate any term, condition, or defense relating to any managed repair arrangement provided in the policy. None of that tells you what your policy says. It tells you what the statutes permit a policy to say, which is the honest boundary of what any contractor can offer you here.
What happens if your policy has a managed repair program and you decline it?
Then the program can change what the policy pays, and Citizens publishes the clearest example. Citizens, which reported 215,131 policies in force on November 13, 2026, runs a Managed Repair Contractor Network that, in its own words, "provides permanent repair services for covered water damage not caused by weather" on its CIT HO-3 and DP-3 forms.
Its FAQ on non-participation, updated August 18, 2026, answers the question directly: "Yes, nonweather water-related losses will be subject to a $10,000 limit." It adds that "payments made from the $3,000 reasonable emergency measures limit will be deducted from the $10,000 water limit." On those forms, for that kind of loss, choosing your own contractor over the program can directly reduce what the policy pays.
A right to repair goes further. In People's Trust Insurance Co. v. Nowroozpour, No. 4D21-720 (Fla. 4th DCA Nov. 24, 2021), the policy "includes a Preferred Contract Endorsement" under which "People's Trust may, at its option, repair the property." The court quoted its earlier decision in Drew v. Mobile USA Insurance Co.: "[W]hen the insurer makes its election to repair, that election is binding upon the insured and creates a new contract." We quote Drew as Nowroozpour quotes it. Where a policy carries a clause like that and the insurer elects to repair, the insurer's contractor is not optional.
Those are two insurers' published terms. Other policies say other things, and the policy form governs, not an FAQ or a blog post. The fuller walkthrough is in can a Florida insurer refuse to pay because you hired your own contractor.
What does the Homeowner Claims Bill of Rights actually tell you to do?
This is the most useful document in the set, and it arrives in the week nobody is reading anything. An insurer issuing a personal lines residential property policy in Florida must provide it within fourteen days after receiving an initial communication about a claim. Its stated purpose is to summarize existing Florida law in simple, nontechnical terms.
Advisory item two tells a policyholder to contact the insurance company before entering into any contract for repairs, to confirm any managed repair policy provisions or optional preferred vendors. Read that phrasing slowly. The state's own summary treats the two as separate categories, which is the distinction the next section turns on.
Advisory item five is worth quoting as well: confirm that the contractor you choose is licensed to do business in Florida, and verify the license and any complaints through the Department of Business and Professional Regulation. The statute's own words are the contractor you choose. It assumes the choice exists in practice without granting it as a statutory right, which is exactly the shape of Florida law here.
Advisory item four is the one people skip: carefully read any contract that requires you to pay out-of-pocket expenses, or a fee based on a percentage of the insurance proceeds you will receive. Two enumerated rights also give you paper. A copy of the insurer's detailed estimate is yours within seven days after the adjuster generates it, and free state mediation is available under most circumstances.
- Verify any Florida license and complaint history yourself at the DBPR licensee search.
- State insurance help, including the mediation program, sits with the Florida Department of Financial Services.
How is a managed repair provision different from an optional vendor list?
The statute draws the line and then stops, which leaves the specifics to each policy. Rather than guess at what any particular program does, treat the difference as a short list of things to establish in writing. Every row below has an answer on paper somewhere.
Notice what is not in the table: any prediction about what your own policy does if you decline. Citizens publishes its answer for its own forms, quoted above. For any other policy the answer is in the policy language, and a contractor who offers you one has crossed a line Florida takes seriously.
| Question to settle | Where the answer lives |
|---|---|
| Is this list a referral, or a provision written into my policy? | The policy form and any endorsement, explained by your insurer or agent |
| Which policy provision is the insurer relying on? | A written answer from the insurer or adjuster that names the provision |
| Who signs the repair agreement, who pays the contractor, and when is payment due? | The repair agreement itself, read before anyone signs it |
| Is the estimate itemized and detailed, as Florida requires for insurance repair work? | Fla. Stat. 489.147(2)(e), and the estimate you are handed |
| Does the company hold a current Florida license, and does it have complaints? | The DBPR licensee search, checked yourself |

What can a Florida restoration contractor tell you about the list, and what can it not?
Florida draws this line by statute, and the penalty shapes how any careful contractor talks to you. Section 489.147(2)(d) makes three things a prohibited practice for a contractor that does not hold a public adjuster license: interpreting policy provisions, advising an insured regarding coverages or duties under the property insurance policy, and adjusting a claim on the insured's behalf. The penalty is disciplinary proceedings plus a fine of up to ten thousand dollars for each violation.
Where exactly that line sits is the subject of its own post: why a Florida contractor will not read your policy for you.
Two more paragraphs of that section are worth knowing, whoever you hire. A contractor may not give you an agreement authorizing repairs without providing a good faith estimate of the itemized and detailed cost of services and materials for repairs undertaken pursuant to a property insurance claim. A contractor may also not offer, deliver, receive or accept any compensation, inducement or reward for the referral of services for which insurance proceeds are payable. That second one is a fair question to ask about any referral, from any direction.
Payment is where these conversations end up, so here is our own answer. We invoice the property owner. You are responsible for payment under your signed agreement, whether or not your insurer pays. Pricing and payment terms are set out in your written agreement. We give you a complete file, with our photos, moisture readings and invoice, to submit with your claim. We do not interpret your policy, negotiate with your insurer, or represent you in your claim. What your insurer pays is set by your policy.

What should you put in writing before a list becomes a decision?
Written matters for an unglamorous reason: a written answer can be read twice, compared with the policy, and shown to whoever helps you next. A phone call cannot. Ask the insurer and any contractor the same way, then read the two sets of answers next to each other. Where they disagree is the thing worth resolving before work starts.
- To the insurer: is the list a referral, or does my policy contain a managed repair provision, and which provision is it.
- To the insurer: is the list optional, or does declining it change what the policy pays?
- To the insurer: is the company exercising a right to repair under the policy, and if so, please cite the provision.
- To any contractor: please provide the itemized and detailed good faith estimate the statute requires before I sign anything.
- To any contractor: does anyone pay or receive a referral fee connected to this work.
What is our view, as a restoration company?
Our view, and it is an opinion, not a legal finding: where an insurer's list is optional, we don't recommend choosing from it. In our view that is a conflict of interest, because the insurer picks the contractor and sends it the work. We found no authority in the sources below that uses that term for insurer vendor programs, and Florida's referral rule in 489.147(2)(c) binds contractors like us, not insurers.
Where your policy carries a managed repair or preferred contractor provision, its terms come first. Read them, and ask your insurer in writing, before you decide.
Where can I read the authorities for myself?
Every quotation above came from the sources below, read on the publishers' own sites on September 21, 2026, and rechecked on November 21, 2026. Statutes and insurer FAQs change every session, so confirm the current text before relying on any of it. For a question about one specific policy, a licensed Florida public adjuster or attorney is who answers it.
| Source | Link |
|---|---|
| Fla. Stat. 627.7142, Homeowner Claims Bill of Rights: advisory items and right-to-repair carve-out | Fla. Stat. 627.7142 |
| Fla. Stat. 627.7011(6)(e), replacement cost: an insurer's right to repair preserved | Fla. Stat. 627.7011 |
| Fla. Stat. 627.702(7), repair at the insurer's own expense in lieu of the money payment | Fla. Stat. 627.702 |
| Fla. Stat. 627.7152(5), assignment agreements do not modify managed repair | Fla. Stat. 627.7152 |
| Fla. Stat. 626.9541, unfair methods of competition, read in full: no repair-choice provision | Fla. Stat. 626.9541 |
| Fla. Stat. 626.9743(3), an auto insurer that requires a particular repair shop: the contrast | Fla. Stat. 626.9743 |
| Fla. Stat. 489.147, prohibited property insurance practices by contractors | Fla. Stat. 489.147 |
| Florida DBPR, licensee and complaint search | DBPR licensee search |
| Florida DFS Division of Consumer Services, including state mediation | DFS Consumer Services |
| Citizens FAQ 3532, the Managed Repair Contractor Network Program (updated May 28, 2026) | Citizens FAQ 3532 |
| Citizens FAQ 3933, the $10,000 limit for non-participants (updated Aug. 18, 2026) | Citizens FAQ 3933 |
| Citizens policies in force, as of November 13, 2026 | Citizens policies in force |
| People's Trust Ins. Co. v. Nowroozpour, No. 4D21-720 (Fla. 4th DCA Nov. 24, 2021), quoting Drew v. Mobile USA Ins. Co. | Nowroozpour opinion (PDF) |
| Sister sites in other markets | restorationdoctors.com and restorationdoctordc.com |



